Negative equity

Go to content

For Practice > Bank for Consultations/ Reform Papers pages > Projects

Negative Equity



What is the Problem
When the acquiring authority crystallises the debt it means claimants may be forced into bankruptcy, or as the negative equity is not compensatable as disturbance compensation, the claimant may be unable to afford the deposit on a new property. S15-17 Compulsory Purchase Act 1965 deals with situation where mortgage debt exceeds the value of land. It provides the Value of land to be agreed between mortgagee, mortgagor and acquiring authority. Agreed sum is payable to mortgagee is obliged to accept payment earlier than that stipulated in the mortgage deed is entitled to be paid his costs of reinvestment; is entitled to loss if the rate of interest secured by the mortgage is higher than can reasonably be expected to be obtained on reinvestment. The proposal is that at any time after a notice to treat has been served (or deemed notice to treat accepted) the mortgagor can serve notice on their mortgagee to transfer their outstanding mortgage to another property. It would also apply to key workers mortgages and shared equity mortgages, to keep the mortgagee’s risk profile broadly similar: Bank has first charge on the new property if the claimant buys a cheaper property than the loan, the amount of the mortgage transferred to the new property should be reduced by the amount of the capital released on downsizing. This keeps the negative equity at the same amount. The change would not apply if claimant already in default on payments; and/or the Mortgagee had commenced proceedings for possession.

Negative equity is crystallised by the acquiring authority. The claimant may have been able to service payments but unable to fund the capital sum still owed to the mortgagee (the negative equity).

What We Seek
Focused attention on this issue in the light of the above.

Notes from Discussion
Important issue and priority for change – can put a whole Order or Bill at risk.

CPA would need to engage with the Lenders or else we are not likely to achieve anything meaningful. This appears to be a UK specific issue which is not reflected in practice in other countries where the acquisition powers are much more focused on securing satisfactory relocation of householders and businesses.

Next Steps/Actions
Primary legislation required in next major reform package.

Back to content